Skip to main content

The Anti-Mask League of San Francisco: Protesting a Mask-Wearing Ordinance During the 1918 Flu Pandemic

Posted on 07/21/2020
by
1d953210-c0e9-486f-acbd-b116cf7f9ea5.jpg
"Wear a Mask or Go To Jail." California (circa 1919)

In early 1919 San Francisco was on the brink of a third wave of influenza. On January 10 of that year the San Jose Mercury Herald reported on the increasing number of deaths under the headline, “Masks Are Advised in S.F.”

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 9.—An increase in the number of deaths from Spanish influenza and a decrease in the number of new cases was announced tonight by city health officials.

For the 24 hours ending at 5 o’clock 465 new cases and 41 deaths were reported. Today’s death total reached the highest figure registered since the recurrence of the disease. Yesterday’s totals were 615 new cases and 27 deaths.

The health committee of the board of supervisors will appear before the supervisors tomorrow with a recommendation that the board enact a new municipal ordinance making compulsory the wearing of anti-influenza masks.

Masks Are Advised in S. F..jpg

One week later the San Diego Union and Daily Bee followed up with this item on the recommended city ordinance:

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 17.—Mayor James Rolph signed a municipal ordinance late today making compulsory the wearing of masks as a measure against the spread of influenza. The ordinance became effective immediately.

Thirty-nine deaths from the disease and 519 cases were announced tonight by the board of health. Yesterday’s totals were 42 deaths and 538 cases.

The article continues:

Representatives of citizens’ organizations opposed to the mask wearing ordinance tonight formed the Anti-Mask league. The announced purpose of the league is “to oppose by all lawful means” the compulsory wearing of masks. Officers of the league said a public mass meeting to take action would be called early next week.

Masks in San Francisco.jpg

A few days later San Jose’s Evening News ran a United Press article reporting on the Anti-Mask League:

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 21.—“Sanitary Spartacans” have broken out in San Francisco in protest of the influenza-mask wearing ordinance. A league was organized last night which is to be known as the “anti-mask” league. At a meeting in the Pacific building $350 was raised to aid in fighting the board of health’s enforcement of the mask wearing ordinance.

From America's Historical Newspapers

Also on Jan. 21, 1919, the Riverside Daily Press published an article on the arrest of protesters in Pasadena who refused to wear masks:

Pasadena, Jan. 21.—Fifty Pasadenans, many prominent, were under arrest here today charged with appearing in public without “flu” masks. The police started enforcement of the “flu” mask ordinance yesterday.

Opposition to mask ordinances was not only a form of political protest against a perceived infringement of the league members’ civil rights. It was also based on both a mistrust of public health officials and a misunderstanding of science. At the Jan. 20 meeting of the Anti-Mask League in San Francisco, members declared “the masks insanitary and useless.”

Reporting on the potential economic ramifications of refusing to wear a mask, the article continues:  

The “flu” mask ordinance all but upset the daily program of the Union Iron works today.

Police of the Potrero station, watching near the iron works gate, nabbed 70 violators within a short time. Among these were foremen and expert mechanics. Most of these were soon released on bail. Potrero station officers said that for two days they have been issuing warnings.

Altogether about a hundred had been taken to the Potrero jail at 10 o’clock.

From America's Historical Newspapers

Noting the efficacy of mask wearing in preventing the spread of the virus and the illogic of those opposing, San Jose’s Evening News printed this on Jan. 25:

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan. 25.—Despite the decided decrease in cases the Anti-Mask League will meet tonight. However, all will wear masks.

Dr. Hassler, health officer, is highly optimistic over the success of the mask wearing. The crowded conditions of hospitals have been greatly relieved.

That the masks are beneficial is pointed out by Dr. Hassler in comparison with yesterday’s 85 cases against 538 cases nine days ago.

From America's Historical Newspapers

News of the decreased cases, as well as the apparent hypocrisy of the league members, was also reported in Idaho’s Twin Falls Daily News:

SAN FRANCISCO, Cal., Jan. 25.—Influenza cases reported yesterday totaled 85, showing a steady decrease in the epidemic here. Deaths reported numbered 20. Thirty-three arrests were made for violation of the masking ordinance.

Despite the evident benefit of the masks, the anti-mask league, wearing masks, will meet tonight.

From America's Historical Newspapers

Three days later the number of cases was still declining, and Mayor Rolph repealed the compulsory mask ordinance, as seen in this article from the Seattle Daily Times.

SAN FRANCISCO, Tuesday, Jan. 28.—Unless there is another flareup of influenza in the meanwhile, San Franciscans may doff their gauze masks Friday. Announcement to this effect was made today by Mayor James Rolph, following a demonstration in the city hall here yesterday against the masking ordinance by representatives of the antimask league. The mayor said that the mask had proved its efficacy and pointed out that since the ordinance became effective on January 20, the epidemic had been practically brought under control.

From America's Historical Newspapers

Despite the San Francisco mayor’s optimistic outlook, the third wave of the influenza pandemic would not recede until June 1919—nearly 18 months after the first wave of early 1918.

Stay in Touch

Receive product news, special offers and invitations, or the acclaimed Readex Report

Sign Up

By clicking "Sign Up", you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.